|
Aching Joints - By Tim Barkley |
"When my husband died, my
kids wanted me to put them on the house. I haven't done it
yet – should I? My daughter lives locally, and she's on my
accounts so that if something happens to me, she can take
over."
Mrs. Selby was visiting her
attorney to discuss updating her will after the death of her
husband of over forty years. She was testing "conventional
wisdom" against professional advice. Her four children had
suggested ways to simplify management of her money during her
life and transfers at death by using joint ownership.
"But I've heard stories," she
continued, "about problems when children are joint owners. It
seems like I might be in for problems. Is that true?"
Her attorney nodded. "Joint
ownership is like the little girl with the little curl – when
it's good, it's very, very good, but when it's bad, it's
horrid.
"The problem comes from the
fact that when you make your child a joint owner on your bank
account or your house, you are actually making them an owner
right now, not just when you die. So their creditors or
divorcing spouse can try to take your assets.
"It can even get worse. I've
had cases where the child who is joint on the accounts doesn't
give the others a fair share. I'm sure your daughter would
never do that, but 'you don't know your family until you've
shared an inheritance with them.' Money brings out the worst
in people."
"That's what I'd heard," Mrs.
Selby replied, "and I know I don't want any of that. But at my
age, I think I need somebody to be able to take over if
something happens to me."
"There's nothing wrong with
that," her attorney assured her, "but you have to do it the
right way.
"There are three ways
somebody can be 'on your accounts' at the bank. The first is
joint ownership. This is a combination of the other two –
control during life and ownership at death – with the addition
of ownership during life. Most people want the first two, but
not the third.
"The second is to name
someone as your agent under power of attorney or 'POA.' That
means they can use your money for you while you're alive. They
can't take your money for themselves, and their creditors
can't get at your money, either.
"Your agent under your POA
doesn't automatically get your money when you die, so we don't
have to worry about her being tempted to do the wrong thing.
"The third is called 'paid on
death' or 'POD.' A POD beneficiary is the person who gets
whatever is left in your account when you die. They don't have
any control over your account during your life; all they have
is the right to get whatever you haven't spent. So their
creditors can't make your life miserable.
"So by using a POA and POD in
combination, you can get the best of both worlds, without the
risks of joint ownership."
"That makes sense," Mrs.
Selby nodded. "How about the house?"
"The problem with joint
ownership is even worse with a house. If you put your kids on
the deed, you can't sell unless they agree, and when you die,
their taxes will be higher when the house is sold. Neither of
those seem very attractive to most of my clients."
Mrs. Selby shook her head,
concurring that these weren't acceptable to her, either.
"You have lots of options,"
advised her attorney. "Here's one I often use.
"Most of my clients want to
keep control of their house during life, but they want the
kids to get the house quickly and simply at their death. Are
those your goals?"
"Yes. My husband and I worked
hard to pay off the mortgage and keep the house up. I mean,
it's my house now that my husband is gone, and the children
don't get it until I'm gone."
Her attorney nodded
agreement. "That's what most of my clients feel. I suggest
that we change the deed to the house so that you keep a 'life
estate' – you can live in the house as long as you want and
it's safe, you can sell it, mortgage or reverse-mortgage it,
lease it, give it away, whatever. But when you die, the house
passes immediately to the kids, with no court filings,
paperwork or delays. Then they can decide whether to sell it,
one can buy the others out, whatever works for them at the
time.
"This gives you the best of
both worlds, without the headaches of joint ownership. What do
you think?"
Mrs. Selby nodded. "I like
both ideas. Let's go with the new deed, and I'll talk to the
bank." |